What Would You Give in Exchange for Your Soul?

I was listening to Bill Monroe the other morning when that old question came around again. What would you give in exchange for your soul? I had heard it before. This time I thought of my own party.

I am a Republican. I know why a man might vote for Donald Trump. He may want a government that spends less, a border the government can control, or a president who remembers that there are towns in Ohio where a man once earned enough in a week to keep a family. Those are things worth taking seriously. Trump took them seriously enough to ask for the man’s vote. He has spent a good deal of time since asking for his obedience.

On January 2, 2021, Trump called Brad Raffensperger, the Republican secretary of state of Georgia. Joe Biden had carried the state. Trump told Raffensperger he wanted to find 11,780 votes, one more than his margin of defeat. Raffensperger disputed Trump’s claims about the count. You can listen to the call yourself. I would ask any Republican who thinks this was an ordinary conversation to imagine hearing a Democratic president make the same request of a Democratic secretary of state. Transcript of the call

Before I went into medicine, I practiced law in southern Ohio. When you lose a case, you can point to a mistake, ask for a review, and make your argument on the evidence. You may be right. You may lose a second time. The number it would take to reverse the result has no bearing on whether you have the evidence to do it. Trump knew exactly how many votes he wanted. That call tells you a good deal about the difference between asking for a fair count and asking a man to deliver the count you need.

Raffensperger had an easy way to avoid some trouble that day. He could have told the president what he wanted to hear and left somebody else to reckon with it. He did his duty instead. I think that is worth remembering the next time someone tells us courage consists in repeating the words of a man who has more power than we do.

I think MAGA has done more damage to the Republican Party than any Democrat could have managed. It has made a man’s loyalty to Donald Trump the test of whether he belongs in his own party. A Republican who once believed Congress ought to guard its powers now has to reckon with what his own side will say if he asks Congress to do its job. A man who used to count a plain answer among the virtues can hear the president evade a question and find himself explaining why it was a bad question to begin with. Do that often enough and you will forget the last time you asked one yourself.

The people who trusted Trump had grievances of their own. They watched jobs go and watched their children go after them. They wanted somebody in Washington to take notice. I have more sympathy for the man who put his hopes in Trump than I do for the Republican officeholder who knows better, has a microphone in front of him, and keeps his mouth shut for fear of losing his seat. He has put a price on his silence. The people back home are paying it.

Mr. Trump bears the greater share of blame. He asked Americans to trust him with an office that belongs to them, and he has treated disagreement as a personal offense. But he did not bargain away the judgment of the Republican Party all by himself. There were men and women who could have stopped and said, in public, what they were willing to say in private. Some still can. They ought to consider how much of their term they have left, and what they mean to do with it.

There will be another election. Before we get to it, I would ask my fellow Republicans to name one thing they would refuse to do, even if Donald Trump asked it of them and even if their refusal cost them a vote. I would like to hear their answers. I think we are past due to give our own.

That is what I heard in Bill Monroe’s question. A Republican may have to give up a seat to keep his word. If he gives up his word to keep his seat, I would ask him what he thinks he saved.

Richard D Kennedy is a retired family physician and former prosecutor from southern Ohio. Read other articles by Richard.